Comparing a R15,000 lithium battery with a R2,700 lead acid battery on price alone hides most of the story. Lithium holds more per battery, can be used deeper, and lasts many more charge cycles. What matters is the cost of each kWh the battery actually delivers over its life, and how many years it lasts with your outages.
How to use it
- Enter the price and size of the two batteries you are comparing, from your quotes. The defaults are a 5.12 kWh 48 V lithium module and a 12 V 100 Ah lead acid battery.
- Enter the depth of discharge and cycle life from each datasheet. Cycle life is always tied to a depth: a lead acid battery rated for 500 cycles at 50% may give only about half that if drained fully every time.
- Set how many outages, or full charge cycles, you expect a week.
How the sum works
Usable energy = size × depth of discharge. Lifetime energy = usable energy × cycle life × round trip efficiency (the share of the charging energy you get back). Cost per kWh delivered = price ÷ lifetime energy. Years = cycle life ÷ (cycles a week × 52).
The calculator also shows how many lead acid batteries give the same usable energy as one lithium battery, and what they cost. Remember that a bank must match the inverter voltage, so lead acid often has to be bought in sets of two or four.
What the sums leave out
- Space and weight: lead acid needs about twice the space and weight for the same usable energy, and flooded batteries need ventilation and topping up.
- Charging speed: lithium recharges faster between back to back outages (see the recharge calculator).
- Warranty terms, which are set by each maker. Compare them in writing.
- Recycling: old lead acid batteries have scrap value. See battery recycling.